liam_on_linux: (Default)
[personal profile] liam_on_linux
Interesting.

I'm playing with the betas of Oneiric Ocelot, which will, in a couple of months, be Ubuntu 11.10. So far I've tried Ubuntu and Lubuntu.

But on one of my machines, I hit a novel problem which I've also been seeing on the Ubuntu support mailing lists... novel GRUB errors, especially one I've not met before:

grub: out of disk

This was with an old dual Athlon box - a Yule present from [livejournal.com profile] kjersti about a decade ago, in fact - which I've resurrected from the back of the garage for possible server duties. Recent reading has exposed a possible bug in its Asus A7-A266D motherboard's EIDE controller which leads to random resets or kernel panics, which is the problem I used to have with it.

I've tried it with an add-in EIDE RAID controller, but it still did it. Now I'm trying it with an add-in SATA controller and it appears to be a whole lot better.

But the odd thing was the simplest possible install - one big root partition and a small swap partition, generated automatically by the "use whole disk" option in the Ubuntu installer - gave this GRUB error.

I reinstalled GRUB. No difference. I moved it to a separate /boot partition after the root partition. Different GRUB error - "unknown filesystem".

So I wiped and reinstalled with Lubuntu, making a separate 128MB ext2 /boot partition at the start of the disk and putting / and swap in logical drives. And lo, it works absolutely fine.

I wonder if the recent versions of GRUB2 have broken something on older kit?

And if they have, how many present-day Linux users remember the days of BIOS drive size limits and of keeping the kernel in the first 1,024 cylinders and the way these things mandated a separate /boot partition?

I fear a lot of people are going to get very frustrated indeed over this...

June 2025

S M T W T F S
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22 232425262728
2930     

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jun. 25th, 2025 07:21 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios